How Some Schools Are Using Weekly Testing To Keep Kids In Class — And COVID Out

Sep 23, 2021
Originally published on October 7, 2021 5:10 pm

On a recent Monday morning, a group of preschoolers filed into the gymnasium at Hillside School in the west Chicago suburbs. These 4- and 5-year-olds were the first of more than 200 students to get tested for the coronavirus that day — and every Monday — for the foreseeable future.

At the front of the line, a girl in a unicorn headband and sparkly pink skirt clutched a plastic zip-top bag with her name on it. She pulled out a plastic tube with a small funnel attached, and Hillside Superintendent Kevin Suchinski then led her to a spot marked off with red tape.

Suchinski had her sit down, while he coached her how to release carefully — but not "spit," which could get messy — about a one-half teaspoon's worth of saliva into the tube.

"You wait a second, you build up your saliva," he told her. "You don't talk, you think about pizza, hamburgers, french fries, ice cream. And you drop it right in there, OK?"

This story was produced in partnership with Kaiser Health News.
&nbsp

The results will come back within 24 hours. Any students who test positive are instructed to isolate, and the school nurse and administrative staff carry out contact tracing.

Hillside was among the first in Illinois to start regular testing. Now, almost half of Illinois' 2 million K-12 students attend schools rolling out similar programs. It's all supported by federal funding that's being channeled through the state health department.

Schools in other states — such as Massachusetts, Maryland, New York and Colorado — are also offering regular testing; Los Angeles public schools have gone further by making it mandatory.

These efforts stand in pretty sharp contrast to states where people are still fighting about basic things such as wearing masks in the classroom. Schools without mask mandates have experienced outbreaks and even teacher deaths.

Within a few weeks of schools reopening, tens of thousands of students across the U.S. were sent home to quarantine. It's a concern because options for K-12 students in quarantine are all over the map — with some schools offering virtual instruction and others providing little or no at-home options.

Suchinski hopes this investment in testing prevents Hillside School from spreading the virus — and keeps kids learning.

"What we say to ourselves is: If we don't do this program, we could be losing instruction because we've had to close down the school," he says.

Avoiding Zoom school at all costs

So far, the parents and guardians of two-thirds of all Hillside students have consented to testing. Suchinski says the school is working hard to get the remaining families on board by educating them about the importance — and benefit — of regular testing.

Every school that can manage it should consider testing students weekly — even twice a week, if possible, says Becky Smith, an epidemiologist at the University of Illinois in Urbana-Champaign, which invented the saliva test Hillside and other Illinois schools are using.

Smith points to several studies — including both peer-reviewed and preliminary research — that suggest rigorous testing and contact tracing are key to keeping the virus at bay in K-12 schools.

"If you're lucky, you can get away without doing testing, [if] nobody comes to school with a raging infection and takes their mask off at lunchtime and infects everybody sitting at the table with them," Smith says. "But relying on luck isn't what we like to do."

Julian Hernandez, a Hillside seventh-grader, says he feels safer knowing that classmates infected with the virus will be prevented from spreading it to others.

"One of my friends — he got it a couple months ago while we was in school," Julian recalls. "[He] and his brother had to go back home. ... They were OK. They only had mild symptoms."

Hillside eighth-grader Amy Muñoz, 13, submits her saliva sample for PCR analysis on Aug. 30. The costs of providing weekly coronavirus testing to all staff and students is covered in part by $11 billion in federal funding in the American Rescue Plan, which is earmarked for testing in K-12 schools.
Christine Herman/WILL

Brandon Muñoz, who's in the fifth grade, says he's glad to get tested because he's too young for the vaccine — and he really doesn't want to go back to Zoom school.

"Because I wanna really meet more people and friends and just not stay on the computer for too long," Brandon says.

Suchinski, the superintendent, says Hillside also improved ventilation throughout the building, installing a new HVAC system and windows with screens in the cafeteria to bring more fresh air in the building.

Regular testing is an added layer of protection, though not the only thing Hillside is relying on: About 90% of Hillside staff are vaccinated, Suchinski says, and students and staff also wear masks.

Setting up testing with outside advice — and funding

Setting up a regular mass testing program inside a K-12 school takes a good amount of coordination, for which Suchinski can vouch.

Last school year, Hillside School administrators facilitated all the saliva sample collection without outside help. This year, the school tapped funding earmarked for K-12 coronavirus testing to hire testers — who coordinate all the logistics of collecting, transporting and processing samples, and reporting results.

A couple of Hillside administrators help oversee the process on Mondays and also facilitate testing for staff plus a twice-a-week testing other days for a limited group of students. Athletes and children in band and extracurriculars test twice a week because they face greater risks of exposure to the virus from these activities.

Compared with a year ago, coronavirus testing is now both more affordable and much less invasive, says Mara Aspinall, who studies biomedical testing at Arizona State University. There's also more help to cover costs.

"The Biden administration has allocated $11 billion to different programs for testing," Aspinall says. "There should be no school — public, private or charter — that can't access that money for testing."

Creating a mass testing program from scratch is a big lift. But more than half of all states have announced programs to help schools access the money and handle the logistics.

If every school tested every student once a week, the $11 billion earmarked for testing would likely run out in a couple of months. (This assumes $20 to buy and process each test, a cost estimate approved by Aspinall.)

Put another way, if a quarter of all U.S. schools tested students weekly, the funds could last the rest of the school year, Aspinall says.

Schools must weigh the benefits and costs of testing

While rapid antigen tests can cost less than PCR tests and provide results faster, they're less reliable for people who are not showing symptoms, says Smith, the epidemiologist.

Highly sensitive saliva-based PCR tests can help identify people before they become infectious. But the person might not get results until the next day. So Smith says she advises schools to use a combination of the two.

For example, schools implementing "test to stay" protocols — in which students who've been exposed to the coronavirus at school are allowed to continue with in-person learning as long as they receive a negative test result every other day for a full week after exposure — can alternate between rapid tests and PCR tests.

In its guidance to K-12 schools, updated on Aug. 5, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention does not make a firm recommendation for this surveillance testing.

Instead, the CDC advises schools that choose to offer testing to work with public health officials to determine a suitable approach, given rates of community transmission and other factors.

Administrators are advised to choose tests that provide results within 24 hours. If testing cannot be conducted in schools safely — and meet other criteria outlined in the guidelines — the agency recommends schools refer students and staff to community-based testing sites.

"The benefits of school-based testing need to be weighed against the costs, inconvenience, and feasibility of such programs to both schools and families," the current guidance says.

The agency previously recommended screening testing at least once a week in all areas experiencing moderate to high levels of community transmission. As of Sept. 15, that included 98% of U.S. counties.

For school leaders looking to explore their options, Aspinall suggests a resource she helped write, which is cited within the CDC guidance to schools: the Rockefeller Foundation's National Testing Action Plan.

The document includes a detailed summary of successful K-12 coronavirus testing programs across the U.S. — and a checklist for school administrators evaluating proposals from testing vendors.

If a school is weak in one area — such as mask-wearing or keeping students in small groups or pods — school leaders should consider strengthening other areas, Smith says.

Vaccines are particularly important as high levels of protection among adults and older children can help protect kids under 12 who are not yet eligible for the vaccine.

"On the other hand, at this point schools are already open," she says. "And it's a lot faster to get a testing protocol in place than to get everybody fully vaccinated."

Taking action and hoping for the best

This spring — when Hillside was operating at about half-capacity and before the more contagious delta variant took over — the school identified 13 positive cases among students and staff via its weekly testing program.

The overall positivity rate of about half a percent made some wonder if all that testing was necessary.

But Suchinski says that by identifying the 13 positive cases, the school perhaps avoided more than a dozen potential outbreaks. Some of the positive cases were among people who weren't showing symptoms but still could have spread the virus.

"Some [other superintendents] are worried that if they do the testing, they would catch asymptomatic kids," he says. "And what I said is: 'So what? That's what we want to do, right?' We want to keep it out."

A couple of weeks into the new school year at Hillside, operating at full capacity, Suchinski says the excitement is palpable.

Nowadays, he says he's balancing feelings of optimism with caution.

"It is great to hear kids laughing. It's great to see kids on playgrounds," Suchinski says.

"At the same time," he adds, "we know that we're still fighting against the delta variant, and we have to keep our guard up."

This story comes from NPR's health reporting partnership with Illinois Public Media, Side Effects Public Media and Kaiser Health News (KHN).

Copyright 2021 Illinois Public Media - WILL. To see more, visit Illinois Public Media - WILL.

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

Coronavirus outbreaks have already shut down classrooms across this country, affecting tens of thousands of students. But one school in Illinois is trying to avoid that fate by testing, testing and testing more.

Here's Christine Herman from member station WILL.

CHRISTINE HERMAN, BYLINE: It's Monday morning at Hillside School, just outside Chicago. A group of preschoolers has just filed into the gymnasium, where they're greeted by their energetic superintendent, Kevin Suchinski.

KEVIN SUCHINSKI: Come on down. Oh, your dress is so pretty. Is today your birthday?

HERMAN: First in line is a girl rocking a unicorn headband and sparkly pink skirt. In her hand is a small plastic tube with a little funnel attached. Suchinski guides her to a spot marked off with red tape and has her sit while he coaches her how to carefully release but not spit some saliva into the tube.

SUCHINSKI: You wait a second. You build up your saliva. You don't talk. You think about pizza, hamburgers, french fries, ice cream. And you drop it right in there, OK? You can sit right here and take off your mask, OK? There you go.

HERMAN: They'll get the results for all these kids - more than 200 - by tomorrow and do it all over again next week. The school was among the first in Illinois to start regular testing. And now almost half of the state's 2 million K-12 students attend schools rolling out similar programs. Hillside goes through eighth grade. And so far, the parents of two-thirds of these students have agreed to the testing.

Seventh-grader Julian Hernandez says, last spring, testing caught a mild infection his classmate didn't know he had.

JULIAN HERNANDEZ: And him and his brother had to go back home, like, two weeks before school ended. They were OK. They only had mild symptoms, really.

HERMAN: Brandon Munoz in the fifth grade says he's glad to get tested because he's too young for the vaccine. And he really doesn't want to go back to Zoom school.

BRANDON MUNOZ: Because I want to really meet more people and friends and just not stay in the computer for too long.

HERMAN: Schools in other states, including Massachusetts, Maryland and Colorado, are also testing regularly. Los Angeles schools have gone so far as to mandate it. That stands in pretty sharp contrast to states where people are still fighting about basic things, like wearing masks. Schools without mask mandates have experienced outbreaks and even teacher deaths.

Suchinski hopes this investment in testing prevents the school from spreading the virus and keeps kids learning.

SUCHINSKI: What we say to ourself is if we don't do this program, we could be losing instruction because we'd have to close down the school. So for the testing program - is another one of our layered mitigations to make sure that we stay open.

HERMAN: Hillside also bumped up ventilation with a new HVAC system and windows with screens in the cafeteria. About 90% of Hillside staff is vaccinated. And everyone wears a mask.

Mara Aspinall studies biomedical testing at Arizona State University. She says, compared to a year ago, COVID testing is now much less invasive and less expensive. And there's more help to cover the costs.

MARA ASPINALL: The Biden administration has allocated $11 billion to different programs for testing. There should be no school - public, private or charter - that can't access that money for testing.

HERMAN: It's a big lift to create a mass testing program from scratch. But more than half of all states have announced programs to help schools get the money and handle the logistics. And while $11 billion sounds like a lot, it would run out in a couple months if every school tested every student once a week.

Epidemiologist Becky Smith is with the University of Illinois. She says twice-a-week testing would be even better. But schools have to weigh what's ideal against what's realistic.

BECKY SMITH: If you're lucky, you can get away without doing testing because nobody comes to school with a raging infection and takes their mask off at lunchtime and infects everybody sitting at the table with them.

HERMAN: But, Smith says, she'd rather schools not rely on luck right now.

For NPR News, I'm Christine Herman in Hillside, Ill.

MARTIN: This story comes from NPR's partnership with Illinois Public Radio and Kaiser Health News.

(SOUNDBITE OF LYMBYC SYSTYM'S "NIGHTFALL") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.