The Massachusetts unemployment rate could race up to more than 25% by June, according to a new policy brief that suggests large federal block grants are the state's best hope for staving off a severe budget crisis.
The Pioneer Institute brief noted that 8.6% of the state's civilian workforce made an unemployment claim during the week ending March 28, ranking the state sixth by that metric. In February, before the COVID-19 pandemic rocked the United States, the state's unemployment rate was 2.5%.
But research authors Greg Sullivan and Charles Chieppo cited a prediction from Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis economist Miguel Faria-e-Castro that the number of unemployed Americans will rise from 5.76 million in February to 52.8 million in June. Under that scenario, about 975,000 Massachusetts residents, or 25%, would be unemployed — up from 106,526 in February.
"Massachusetts should join with other states to lobby Congress for large block grants to assist state governments during this unprecedented time," Sullivan, a former state inspector general and Massachusetts House member, said. "The alternative is a state budget crisis of unprecedented severity."
The pandemic's grip has slowed business activity, with some businesses closed altogether. At the same time, according to the report (PDF), it has reduced consumer spending, MBTA revenue and pension fund investment earnings while also forcing major increases in government spending.
"It is critically important for state government leaders to formulate a best case/worst case analysis of the potential effects of the COVID-19 recession on state government revenues and expenditures and make plans to address the crisis," the authors conclude in their report.
Four weeks into the COVID-19 state of emergency, Massachusetts House and Senate leaders have not outlined plans for tackling a budget for fiscal 2021, which begins July 1. A hearing scheduled for Tuesday to evaluate revenue impacts of the pandemic was postponed for a week due to a livestreaming failure.
Unemployment in the U.S. hit 25% in 1933, but that milestone occurred four years after the 1929 stock market crash, according to the brief, which notes the national unemployment rate didn't return to the pre-market crash level of 3.2% until 1943.
The policy brief did not include an estimate of when employment levels might bounce back, but the researchers observed that other economists have projected that unemployment will not rise as much as Faria-e-Castro estimates. Goldman Sachs forecast a 15% rate by mid-2020, according to the report, and St. Louis Federal Reserve President James Bullard forecast "that it will skyrocket to 30%, but that the economy will then snap back strongly."
During the Great Recession, unemployment peaked in Massachusetts at 8.3%, according to the report, and state income tax revenues fell from $12.5 billion in fiscal 2008 to $10.1 billion in fiscal 2010. Sales tax revenue declined by 5% during that recession, but the closing of non-essential business during the COVID-19 pandemic points to deeper near-term declines in that major revenue source.
The researchers said it's difficult to estimate state income tax declines that would result from such a dramatic rise in unemployment.
"The biggest unknown is how long stay-at-home directives and employer shut-downs will last," the report said. "Also unknown is the duration of the recovery period and the extent to which many small and medium-sized employers will suffer long-term or permanent damage resulting from cash-flow problems during the COVID-19 shut-down."
The federal law known as the CARES Act, or Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act, is expected to steer $2.67 billion in aid to Massachusetts, and talks are underway about another federal stimulus or relief bill.
The CARES Act also temporarily increases the federal matching rate for Medicaid, provides an additional $600 a week for up to four months to everyone collecting jobless benefits, expands categories of workers eligible for unemployment benefits, and funds 13 additional weeks of benefits beyond the normal unemployment time limit. Those measures, according to the brief, will help state finances because unemployment benefits are taxable, but the CARES Act would not help Massachusetts to fund its usual 30 weeks of unemployment benefits.
As requests pile up for new state aid, Pioneer Institute Executive Director Jim Stergios called state block grants "a must," warning that major drains on state unemployment or stabilization fund reserves "would undermine our fiscal health and weaken our ability to conduct the people's business."
Sullivan served two terms as state inspector general and 17 years in the Massachusetts House. Chieppo, a senior fellow at the institute, previously worked as policy director in the state's Executive Office of Administration and Finance.
